Inkscape.org
Beyond the Basics Path > Combine Groups Bug - Windows 11 V1.4
  1. #1
    COD COD @COD
    *

    Just need a verification if this is a bug. If so - I will report it for a possible fix in v1.4.1. 

    With v 1.3.2 I could do a Path>Combine on nested groups of objects with no issue. I didn't have to do a "deep" ungroup prior to Path>Combine.

    With v1.4, it will not work unless I deep ungroup or (the interesting part) do Path>Combine twice.

    Thanks 

    Edit: Lol - nevermind. I didn't convert the symbols to objects first. Sorry
     

     

  2. #2
    Polygon Polygon @Polygon🌶

    Works here on macOS like in 1.3.2:

  3. #3
    COD COD @COD

    Polygon - open the layers dialog after you do a combine. Do you see a ton of empty "user" objects? 

    Now do a save. Reload the file and open the XML editor. DO you still see those empty "user" objects?

    Now - do a deep ungroup - this will eliminate the empty "user" objects.

     

    If no - then I will report this as a WIndows version issue. If yes - I will report as all platforms issue. 

    OMG - lol - i'm really getting senile. haha


     

     

  4. #4
    Polygon Polygon @Polygon🌶

    This might come from using Symbols - not sure though.

  5. #5
    COD COD @COD

    Polygon - 

    I am sure it is a symbols issue but let me explain why I know for a fact that I am going senile - lol.

    For 2+ years my normal workflow for doing this was to deep unclone symbols then a deep ungroup - then do a combine. In other words - I discovered this issue 2+ years ago. 
    For some reason this morning I didn't follow this workflow. I went straight to Path>Combine. The combine was buried inside the group and when I clicked the group - it appeared to not combine. 

    I opened the layers dialog and found it inside the group. That is when I discovered all the empty "user" objects.  

    I think I will report this. I don't think the developers intended all these empty "user" objects after a combine of the symbols. 
     

  6. #6
    COD COD @COD

    Reported:
    https://gitlab.com/inkscape/inbox/-/issues/11210

     

  7. #7
    Polygon Polygon @Polygon🌶

    Good job. Thanks. 🙏 

  8. #8
    COD COD @COD

    More info that might help fix the issue of Path>Combine with symbols:

    Fracture and Flatten is working correctly with grouped symbols. Both will create new paths and eliminate the "empty" user objects.

Inkscape Inkscape.org Inkscape Forum Beyond the Basics Path > Combine Groups Bug - Windows 11 V1.4